Pilot A Panel, Discussion Leader - Part 8

Evaluation Guide for "Pilot A Panel"

Note to the Evaluator: The purpose of this project was for the group leader to select panelists and moderate a panel discussion. The information should be adequately divided among the panelists so that no overlap of information occurs. The moderator should give evidence that he or she has carefully limited the scope of the topic for presentation to be managed within the 30-40 minute time period. In addition to your oral evaluation, please write answers to the questions below.

· In opening the session, did the moderator clearly explain the topic for discussion in terms of a stated problem?
· Did the moderator define the common goals or purpose of the panel?
· Did the moderator introduce each panelist and his or her topic for presentation?
· Did the moderator limit the speaking time of each panelist from five to seven minutes?
· Did the moderator repeat questions from the audience and limit panelist's responses to two minutes?
· In closing, did the moderator thank the panelists and the audience?
· As evaluator, call for a discussion of the points and suggestions for improvement.